Understanding Control Philosophy in Automation

Have you ever wondered how control systems work in process automation? What is the guiding principle behind their operation? Control philosophy plays a crucial role in shaping the strategies for effective control and automation. Let’s dive into the world of control theory and explore the key elements that make up the control philosophy.

Key Takeaways:

  • Control philosophy is a document that describes the operating principles and variables of a control program in automation systems.
  • It includes the control narrative, which explains the system’s programming conditions and the plant’s operation philosophy.
  • The control narrative serves as a base for developing control logics and provides a comprehensive understanding of the process and its performance.
  • PLC-based systems and DCS are two approaches to process automation, each with its own advantages and considerations.
  • Regardless of the system chosen, control philosophy remains a fundamental aspect of control engineering and feedback control in industrial automation.

What is a Control Narrative?

A control narrative is a crucial document that outlines the control philosophy and identifies the variables involved in the control program. It provides an in-depth explanation of the system’s operation by incorporating the main operating principles. By specifying the programming conditions, the control narrative establishes the foundation for effective control system development.

The control narrative encompasses a wide range of variables, including field instrument parameters, pumps, valves, equipment status signals, and more. These variables play a vital role in shaping the control program and ensuring its smooth functioning.

Utilized in various aspects of process automation, the control narrative serves multiple purposes. First, it helps set operational procedures, providing guidance for process engineers on the plant floor. Furthermore, it serves as a valuable resource for operator training, enabling operators to gain a comprehensive understanding of the equipment and variables involved. Lastly, it serves as a starting point for control system programmers, assisting them in writing configuration code for the control system.

“The control narrative is a dynamic document that acts as a roadmap for control system development. It bridges the gap between theoretical concepts and real-world implementation, laying the groundwork for efficient and intelligent process control.” – Process Control Engineer, John Smith

With its comprehensive coverage of operating philosophies, variables, and field instrument parameters, the control narrative plays a vital role in ensuring effective control system implementation and optimization.

Example Control Narrative Table:

VariableDescriptionOperating Range
TemperatureMeasurement of process temperature0-100°C
PressureMeasurement of process pressure0-10 bar
Flow RateMeasurement of fluid flow rate0-1000 L/min

Table: Example Control Narrative Table

The table above provides an example of how variables can be documented within a control narrative. It includes columns for the variable name, description, and operating range, allowing for clear and concise communication of essential information.

By utilizing a well-defined control narrative, organizations can enhance operational efficiency, improve operator training, and enable control system programmers to effectively configure automation systems.

The Purpose of a Control Narrative

The control narrative serves multiple purposes in the field of automation. It is a vital document that allows process engineers to establish and record operational procedures on the plant floor. By outlining the step-by-step processes and variables involved, the control narrative provides a framework for efficient and consistent plant operations.

Furthermore, the control narrative serves as a valuable resource for operator training. It offers comprehensive documentation that helps operators understand the equipment and variables involved in the process. This knowledge is crucial for maintaining optimal performance and troubleshooting any issues that arise during operation.

Additionally, the control narrative serves as a starting point for control system programmers. Even if they have limited experience with a specific process, the control narrative provides the necessary information for them to write configuration code for the control system. This ensures that the control system is tailored to the unique requirements of the process, maximizing its effectiveness.

Overall, the control narrative plays a crucial role in providing a comprehensive understanding of the process and its performance. It serves as a foundation for developing control logics for automation systems and optimizing operational procedures, operator training, and control system programming.

Key Points:

  • The control narrative enables process engineers to set and record operational procedures.
  • It serves as documentation for operator training, helping operators understand the process equipment and variables.
  • The control narrative provides a starting point for control system programmers to write configuration code.
  • Its purpose is to provide a comprehensive understanding of the process and its performance.

What is Included in a Control Narrative?

A control narrative encompasses various essential elements that provide a comprehensive understanding of the control process. Let’s explore the key components of a control narrative.

Process Overview

The control narrative begins with a process overview, outlining the basic description of the overall system process. It includes the purpose of the process and provides functional unit descriptions, giving a clear understanding of how the entire system operates.

Equipment List

The control narrative includes an equipment list, detailing all the physical components utilized in the process. From pumps and valves to sensors and actuators, every vital piece of equipment is listed, ensuring a comprehensive overview of the system.

Software Components

Software components play a crucial role in the control process, and the control narrative lists them to provide a complete understanding. These include control loops, calculations, and other software modules involved in regulating the system’s variables and performance.

Alarms

In any control system, alarms play a crucial role in alerting operators to abnormal conditions. The control narrative outlines the various alarms, including non-default alarms specific to the process. This ensures that operators are well-informed about potential issues that require attention.

Interlock and Sequence

Interlock and sequence descriptions are a key part of the control narrative. They outline step-by-step procedures and corrective actions to be taken in specific scenarios. This helps operators and control system programmers alike in managing and responding to different situations effectively.

Concurrent Tasks

Concurrent tasks refer to normal process control functions that can be performed independently of sequences. The control narrative defines these tasks, ensuring that every aspect of process control is clearly documented and understood.

“A control narrative provides a comprehensive overview of the control process, including the process overview, equipment list, software components, alarms, interlock and sequence, and concurrent tasks.”

The control narrative serves as a valuable reference document for operators, control system programmers, and engineers involved in the process control. It ensures a common understanding of the system and facilitates effective decision-making and troubleshooting.

Control Narrative ElementsDescription
Process OverviewProvides a basic description of the overall system process and its purpose.
Equipment ListLists all the physical components used in the process, including pumps, valves, and sensors.
Software ComponentsDocuments the control loops, calculations, and other software modules involved in the control process.
AlarmsDescribes the various alarms, including non-default alarms linked with the process, to alert operators of abnormal conditions.
Interlock and SequenceOutlines step-by-step procedures and corrective actions to be followed in specific scenarios.
Concurrent TasksDefines normal process control functions that can be performed independently of sequences.

The Debate between PLC-Based Systems and DCS

When it comes to process automation, there is an ongoing debate in the industry regarding the use of PLC-based systems versus distributed control systems (DCS). While some argue that a single integrated architecture based on PLCs and/or programmable automation controllers (PACs) is the best approach to total plant automation, DCS vendors have also introduced PLC and PAC products as offerings.

The primary logic offered for using a single PLC-based system is to have one control architecture for the entire plant. This approach simplifies system design, maintenance, and troubleshooting, as all functions are integrated into one system. Additionally, PLC-based systems are commonly used for non-core functions within a process, such as auxiliary equipment control and monitoring.

On the other hand, DCS systems have traditionally been the primary solution for process automation, particularly for controlling core processes. DCS provides a scalable and distributed control environment, with a high level of redundancy and fault tolerance. It offers advanced functionalities, such as batch processing and advanced regulatory control, making it suitable for complex process requirements.

To better understand the differences between these two systems, let’s compare their key features:

PLC-Based SystemsDCS
Designed for non-core functionsPrimarily used for controlling core processes
Single integrated architectureScalable and distributed control environment
Easy system design, maintenance, and troubleshootingHigh level of redundancy and fault tolerance
Suitable for smaller plants or specific applicationsCapable of handling complex process requirements

Ultimately, the choice between PLC-based systems and DCS depends on the specific requirements of the plant. Smaller plants or applications with simpler control needs may find PLC-based systems more cost-effective and easier to implement. However, for larger plants with complex processes and comprehensive automation needs, DCS continues to be the preferred solution.

No matter the system chosen, it is essential to carefully consider the automation strategy and select the solution that aligns with the plant’s goals and objectives. The key is to leverage the strengths of each system and design a control philosophy that maximizes efficiency, safety, and productivity.

Conclusion

Control philosophy is a critical component in the development of effective automation strategies and process control systems in the realm of industrial automation. By providing a comprehensive understanding of the process and its performance, control philosophy serves as the foundation for the creation of control logics within automation systems. It outlines the operating principles and variables of a control program, guiding engineers and programmers in designing and implementing robust automation solutions.

The ongoing debate between PLC-based systems and distributed control systems (DCS) reflects the diverse approaches to process automation. While proponents argue for a singular PLC-based architecture, others advocate for the versatility of DCS systems. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on the specific requirements of each plant and its unique automation needs.

Regardless of the chosen system, control philosophy remains an essential aspect of control engineering and feedback control in industrial automation. It enables engineers to formulate effective strategies and develop control logics that optimize operational efficiency, productivity, and safety. As automation continues to revolutionize various industries, a solid control philosophy will be instrumental in achieving successful automation strategies and maximizing the potential of industrial processes.

FAQ

What is a control philosophy?

The control philosophy is a document that describes the operating principles and variables of a control program. It includes the control narrative, which explains the system’s programming conditions and the plant’s operation philosophy. The control narrative also specifies alarm set points and shutdown values.

What is a control narrative?

A control narrative is a document that describes the control philosophy and identifies the variables in the control program. It includes the main operating principles and provides an explanation of how the system operates. The control narrative specifies the conditions for the system’s programming and includes variables such as field instrument parameters, pumps, valves, and equipment status signals.

What is the purpose of a control narrative?

The control narrative serves multiple purposes. It allows process engineers to set out and record operational procedures on the plant floor. It serves as documentation for operator training, helping them understand the process’s equipment and variables. It also provides a starting point for control system programmers to write configuration code for the control system, even if they have little experience with the specific process.

What is included in a control narrative?

A control narrative includes several elements. It starts with a process overview, providing a basic description of the overall system process, including its purpose and major functional unit descriptions. It also includes an equipment list, specifying all the physical equipment used in the process. Software components, such as control loops and calculations, are also documented in the control narrative. Alarms, including non-default alarms linked with the process, are described. Interlock and sequence descriptions outline step-by-step procedures and corrective actions. Finally, concurrent tasks, which are normal process control functions independent of sequences, are defined.

What is the debate between PLC-based systems and DCS?

There is an ongoing debate in the industry regarding the use of PLC-based systems versus distributed control systems (DCS) for process automation. Some argue that a single integrated architecture based on PLCs and/or programmable automation controllers (PACs) is the best approach to total plant automation. DCS vendors have also introduced PLC and PAC products as offerings. Both systems have their advantages and it ultimately depends on the specific requirements of the plant.

What role does the control philosophy play?

Control philosophy plays a crucial role in shaping effective automation and process control strategies. It provides a comprehensive understanding of the process and its performance, serving as a base for developing control logics for automation systems.

Source Links


Enjoyed the article? 

You can find more great content here:

About the Author Walid Ben

Walid Ben. is a seasoned process engineer with 12 years of diverse experience, from operations support to leading roles in mega projects, commissioning, and startups. Driven by an entrepreneurial spirit, I founded Induskills.com an educational platform that offers hands-on tutorials and courses, cutting through theory to provide practical skills.